
Is there really no substitute for experience?
While Japan can be quite unabashed in its admiration of the sexy female form, in picking dating partners, Japanese men often display a preference for women who haven’t been in many relationships before. But do women similarly gravitate towards guys who are relative newcomers to the dating arena?
In an attempt to find out, female interest Internet portal My Navi Woman polled 117 women between the ages of 22 and 34, asking them whether they prefer a man who’s used to spending time with a woman or one who isn’t. To clarify, the survey wasn’t specifically asking about a man’s sexual experience, merely whether or not he was experienced in going on dates.
When the votes were tallied 68.1 percent said they’d rather date a guy who’s doesn’t have that many dates under his belt. Many in this camp cited concerns about how faithful a guy would be after significantly sampling the rest of the dating pool, and one spoke of her insecurities by saying, “If he’s dated a lot, I think he’d be comparing me to women he’s gone out with in the past.”
In a more positive sense, others who preferred an inexperienced guy theorized that such a relationship would be more enjoyable for both them and their hypothetical boyfriend. “Things would feel fresher and more exciting,” opined one woman, while another added that a more-or-less blank dating slate allows a couple to grow together as equals.
The other side of the debate, though, also made some convincing arguments for an experienced guy. “I knew a guy before who had a lot of dating experience,” recalled one survey participant, “and he knew a lot of restaurants that women like, so it was always fun going out with him.” Others mentioned that more experienced men were more proactive in planning dates, a trait that’s often seen as desirable by Japanese women.
That said, while roughly a third of the respondents had a preference for experienced men, that seemed to be more a reflection of their perceived confidence and capability, so it’s probably best for a guy to let those qualities speak for themselves, and not expand too much on how many women he dated before acquiring them.
Source: My Navi Woman via Otakumu
Top image: Pakutaso
Follow Casey on Twitter, where his level of dating experience is a closely guarded secret.

Rich and bald or handsome and poor? Survey asks Japanese women who’d they’d rather marry
Survey asks Japanese women if they could date a man who earns less money than they do
Is it OK to split the bill on a date in Japan? Survey asks what women and men of different ages think
No doctors or hairdressers! Survey asks Japanese women what professions they don’t want to date
Starbucks Japan reveals new Tsukimi Moon-Viewing drinkware and gifts for autumn 2026
Japan’s first fall color forecast for 2026 is here!
A real-world Pokémon Poké Ball hotel is opening in Japan at a still-secret location [Video]
Japan’s revolving sushi restaurant king Sushiro coming to U.S. this fall with high prices, no tipping
The mystery of Port Store, the Japanese convenience store that looks like a Lawson rip-off
Tamagotchi evolves into a ring for its 30th anniversary, preorders now open
Elderly couple donates 400 million yen to erect Myaku-Myaku statue in Osaka
Japan Railways announces unlimited-ride train pass for fall travel
Mini CRT-lookalike Final Fantasy figurines are awesome pixel art music boxes [Video]
Lawson convenience store opens its first mobile, trailer-style location in Japan
Japan’s final Penguin Suica train cards have already shipped, and when they’re gone, they’re gone
Studio Ghibli unveils new anime calendars and diary planners for 2027
Solo travel in Japan: Hidden beer garden in Tokyo is a haven for single visitors
Hobonichi unveils new 2027 planners, diaries and stationery with One Piece, Suica Penguin, Hello Kitty and a must-buy Mini Techo
Farewell Final Ceremony announced for Tokyo’s life-size Gundam statue, will stream live
Family Mart releases new Human Made Cup Noodle in Japan, with freebies for Nigo fans
Japan approves foreign resident visa renewal fee increases of up to 967 percent, starts soon
One Piece Day 2026 brings new art, music, and new cast announcements
Hikaru Utada sings new song in Shinkansen commercial for Japan’s Supreme Class cabins
12-year-old British girl who went missing in Tokyo found safe after visiting anime sites around Yokohama
7-year-old boy left behind on Mt. Fuji by his own dad
Sushi Bus: Japan’s first conveyor-belt bus lets you eat sushi while sightseeing around Tokyo
Pokémon Center Online designates first Pokémon items that will require Japanese ID card to buy
Japanese toilet aims to attract foreign tourists but not everybody is happy about it
New Japanese vending machine at Shinkansen station sells cups of ice on platform
Study finds hundreds of people in Indonesia legally named after Naruto, Inuyasha, other anime stars
Japan announces sudden 400-percent increase in visa fees for foreigners entering the country
Japan’s human washing machines will go on sale to general public, demos to be held in Tokyo
Studio Ghibli has a new anime out, and there’s only one place in the world where you can see it
Starbucks Japan releases new drinkware and goods for Valentine’s Day
Starbucks Japan releases new sakura goods and drinkware for cherry blossom season 2026
Japan’s newest Shinkansen has no seats…or passengers [Video]
Tokyo subway installing new ticket gates that don’t accept payment through Suica or other IC cards
Japanese ninja certification exam attracts 131 candidates from Japan and abroad
Salomon releases Japan-exclusive Mt. Fuji hiking gear that doubles as an amazing souvenir
Put sesame oil in your coffee? Japanese maker says it’s the best way to start your day【Taste test】
Survey asks Japanese women if they could marry a man who’s rich but ugly
Japanese college women pick between men who’re short and handsome or tall and plain in survey
40 percent of Japanese women in survey say they’d be OK with a “Christmas Eve-only” boyfriend
Japanese women in survey reveal surprisingly low hurdle men have to clear to get a Christmas date
Overweight, bald, or cheap? Japanese women pick the man they’d least want to marry in survey
How much do Japanese men and women pay on dates? Survey finds large gap
Does a guy lose all chance with a Japanese woman if he doesn’t pay for the first date?【Survey】
How do Japanese women feel about going Dutch on a date? Survey investigates, finds gap
Japanese women list the top 10 romantic scenarios by which they’d like to meet a new boyfriend
A large number of men prefer women who are attracted to other women, study says
What are the most and least attractive hobbies for Japanese men and women? Survey investigates
Japanese survey asks exactly why people broke up with their partners
Roughly 40 percent of single Japanese men in their 20s have never been on a date, survey says