A “cancer cluster” detected in kids near the Fukushima disaster is probably due to the increased examination of these children, not because of the disaster itself, according to epidemiologist Norman Kleiman of Columbia University.
Marc Silver of National Geographic interviewed Kleiman in a post published yesterday.
The Japanese government’s announcement that they had found 33 cases of thyroid cancer in 254,000 children and adolescents in Fukushima Prefecture got a lot of media attention because it’s significantly higher than the one to two cases per million kids that are normally found.
However, any recent increase in the number of thyroid cases is likely due to increased screening after the disaster. There’s been more screening because a similar nuclear disaster in Chernobyl did cause an uptick in thyroid cancer cases in children. The United Nations said last year that thyroid cancer rates were not expected to rise after Fukushima.
It’s unlikely that that new thyroid cases are children who were exposed to Fukushima radiation since it would generally take another one to three years before tumors are big enough to appear on tests.
If you’re going to screen that many children, you’re going to find more cases than you normally [would], because you’re looking for something. I suspect if you took the same number of children in Montana and did the same [screening], you’d probably find a similar ratio.
The problem is that more testing can also lead to unnecessary action, like surgery or other aggressive treatments. These actions can have more negative side effects than not treating the issue at all, especially if the cancer would not have progressed or caused other unfortunate symptoms. (We’ve seen the same thing happen for over-screening of prostate and breast cancer).
Kleiman explains: “Many of these [detected] cancers would have gone undiagnosed, or might not have progressed.”
Kleiman goes on to explain why this is different than the thyroid cancer cluster after Chernobyl. Read at NatGeo »
Incidences of thyroid cancer on the rise among Fukushima children
That time Seiji called JASRAC to ask why he didn’t get paid royalties for his song being on TV
The best Starbucks Japan Frappuccinos we want to drink again in 2026
Osaka hotel has amazing all-you-can-eat takoyaki and kushikatsu breakfast buffet
7 great places to see Mt. Fuji from without having to climb it
New Japanese menstrual product seeks to help women spot unidentified iron deficiencies
Mikado Coffee is a 76-year-old coffee chain with a major celebrity connection
Shiratani Unsuikyo: The breathtaking anime setting where Princess Mononoke was born
7-Eleven Japan’s ramen-cooking robot whipped us up a bowl of noodles【Taste test】
Why is there a wrestling ring in the Underground Arena fighting bar in Kabukicho?
Harajuku’s new permanent Tamagotchi shop is filled with cuteness and a surprising lack of poop
Starbucks Japan ready to get Year of the Horse started with adorable drinkware and plushies【Pics】
Cyberpunk anime meets traditional culture in Ghost in the Shell gold leaf Japanese changing screens
Hello Kitty Choco Egg figures are an adorable trip through three periods of Japanese pop culture【Pics】
We found possibly the quietest Japanese-style hotel in Tokyo’s bustling Shinjuku district
Japan’s otoshidama tradition of giving kids money at New Year’s gets a social welfare upgrade
Sumo Sanrio! Hello Kitty and pals team up with Japan Sumo Association for new merch【Pics】
More Than a Capsule Stay: Why Solo Travelers Choose “global cabin Yokohama Chinatown”
Japan’s oldest largetooth sawfish in captivity back on display in Mie Prefecture
7-Eleven Japan starts new temporary luggage storage service in over 300 branches
Disillusionment at Tsukiji’s tourist-target prices led us to a great ramen restaurant in Tokyo
Starbucks teams up with 166-year-old Kyoto doll maker for Year of the Horse decorations【Photos】
Tokyo considering law requiring more trash cans following litter increase in heavily touristed area
Tokyo’s Tsukiji sushi neighborhood asks tour groups to stay away for the rest of the month
Tokyo event lets you travel back in time, for free, to celebrate 100 years since Showa era start
Sanrio theme park in Japan announces plans to expand into a Sanrio resort
Japan may add Japanese language proficiency, lifestyle classes to permanent foreign resident requirements
Stamina-destroying “Paralysis Noodles” are Tokyo’s newest over-the-top ramen innovation
Survey asks foreign tourists what bothered them in Japan, more than half gave same answer
Japan’s human washing machines will go on sale to general public, demos to be held in Tokyo
Japan’s deadliest food claims more victims, but why do people keep eating it for New Year’s?
We deeply regret going into this tunnel on our walk in the mountains of Japan
Studio Ghibli releases Kodama forest spirits from Princess Mononoke to light up your home
Major Japanese hotel chain says reservations via overseas booking sites may not be valid
Put sesame oil in your coffee? Japanese maker says it’s the best way to start your day【Taste test】
No more using real katana for tourism activities, Japan’s National Police Agency says
Starbucks Japan reveals new sakura drinkware collection, inspired by evening cherry blossoms
Updated cherry blossom forecast shows extra-long sakura season for Japan this year
Leave a Reply