
They say it’s a charm.
A popular fixture of the Japanese cityscape is the many plastic food samples that grace the windows of restaurants and other food retailers. These fake foods are crafted with such amazing attention to detail that they’re works of art in their own right.
Unfortunately, this can be a source of problems for the sellers of foods themselves when these lifelike dishes aren’t safely locked in showcases. Just ask the staff at Andrew’s Eggtart, who’ve been having trouble telling their fake tarts from the real ones.
▼ Andrew’s Eggtart is a division of Lord Stow’s Bakery, in which Andrew and Lord Stow are the same guy
In late October, an incident occurred in which a customer was accidentally served five plastic tarts when staff mistook them for actual fresh tarts. The Macau-based franchise which usually has locations in Osaka, Nagoya, and Kagoshima, opened up a temporary stand in JR Tottori Station and customers flocked at the chance to get the rare treat. It would seem that in all the ruckus the inedible order of tarts got handed out by mistake.
The company explained that part of the reason was that these particular food samples were designed to be hollow to save production costs. This also makes them much lighter than solid plastic sculptures and harder to distinguish from the weight of real tarts. In addition, attention to the samples’ look was so detailed that they even had the distinct color and texture of tarts that were baked off-site and cooled as opposed to freshly baked ones.
It’s that very attention to detail that made a lot of online commenters say they’d consider themselves lucky to be given samples by mistake.
“I’d totally rather have the samples.”
“I think the company who made the sample should feel proud.”
“Recent food replicas are amazing and really hard to tell from the real thing.”
“A long time ago my father bought some souvenir snacks on a trip but they turned out to be samples. He couldn’t return them either because it was too far away, but that was fine by me.”
“I wonder how you can make it clear without ruining the appearance. Maybe gluing it to a nice dish?”
“There is such a thing as being too high-quality.”
“It’s not like those silicon packets, but still probably a good idea to put a DO NOT EAT warning on them.”
“I wouldn’t mind buying a sample, but hopefully I’d realize it before trying to eat it.”
According to Andrew’s Eggtart, a sample costs about three times as much as the 209 yen ($1.50) price of an actual tart, so anyone who ends up with one would be getting a bargain. Luckily, in this most recent case, the customers were honest and brought the samples back for an exchange without any complaints.
This is actually the second time that Andrew’s Eggtart had this problem with a similar mistake occurring last January. After that happened, measures were put in place to prevent a reoccurrence such as clearly explaining to part-time staff which tarts were real and even refraining from placing the fake tarts out unless a manager was present.
However, in the case of temporary tart stands, staff is outsourced to local human resources not as well-trained or experienced to deal with such realistic food samples. Andrew’s Eggtart now says they will improve temporary location training as well to prevent this from happening a third time.
Source: Shukan Josei Prime, Twitter
Top image: YouTube/Lord Stow’s Bakery
● Want to hear about SoraNews24’s latest articles as soon as they’re published? Follow us on Facebook and Twitter!

10 times to avoid traveling in Japan in 2026
Our 52-year-old pole dancing reporter shares his tips for achieving your New Year’s exercise goal
We ate sushi made from Japan’s most expensive tuna ever【Taste test】
Ramen restaurant’s English menu prices are nearly double its Japanese ones, denies discriminating
Using red sushi rice makes a real difference, if it’s paired with the right fish【Taste test】
10 times to avoid traveling in Japan in 2026
Our 52-year-old pole dancing reporter shares his tips for achieving your New Year’s exercise goal
We ate sushi made from Japan’s most expensive tuna ever【Taste test】
Ramen restaurant’s English menu prices are nearly double its Japanese ones, denies discriminating
Using red sushi rice makes a real difference, if it’s paired with the right fish【Taste test】
Umamusume anime girl plushie recalled for having parts she absolutely should not have【Pics】
End-of-the-Line Exploring in Japan: Tokyo’s Mita Line can give you all the nothing you want【Pics】
Why Do Foreigners Like Japan so Much? We Head to Comiket 82 to Find Out!
Japan Sets Guinness Record for Synchronized Mascot Dancing 【Video】
Adorable New “Pokemomo” Brand Goods Coming to Pokemon Center Stores Across Japan
Japanese beef bowl chain Sukiya’s 2026 Smile Box lucky bag basically pays for itself
Hayao Miyazaki says Happy New Year to Studio Ghibli fans with new art for Year of the Horse
Starbucks Japan ready to get Year of the Horse started with adorable drinkware and plushies【Pics】
Top Japanese cosplayer Enako returns to Comiket after 6 years, creates mayhem with admirers
Cup Noodle tries an authentic Jiro-style ramen, but something’s not quite right
The best Starbucks Japan Frappuccinos we want to drink again in 2026
We revisited Sweets Paradise after a decade to see if Japan’s dessert buffet still delivers
That time Seiji called JASRAC to ask why he didn’t get paid royalties for his song being on TV
7-Eleven Japan starts new temporary luggage storage service in over 300 branches
Disillusionment at Tsukiji’s tourist-target prices led us to a great ramen restaurant in Tokyo
Starbucks teams up with 166-year-old Kyoto doll maker for Year of the Horse decorations【Photos】
Tokyo considering law requiring more trash cans following litter increase in heavily touristed area
Tokyo’s Tsukiji sushi neighborhood asks tour groups to stay away for the rest of the month
Tokyo event lets you travel back in time, for free, to celebrate 100 years since Showa era start
Japan may add Japanese language proficiency, lifestyle classes to permanent foreign resident requirements
Lacquerware supplier to emperor of Japan and Pokémon team up for new tableware
Starbucks Japan releases new zodiac chilled cup drink for 2026
Survey asks foreign tourists what bothered them in Japan, more than half gave same answer
Japan’s human washing machines will go on sale to general public, demos to be held in Tokyo
We deeply regret going into this tunnel on our walk in the mountains of Japan
Studio Ghibli releases Kodama forest spirits from Princess Mononoke to light up your home
Major Japanese hotel chain says reservations via overseas booking sites may not be valid
Put sesame oil in your coffee? Japanese maker says it’s the best way to start your day【Taste test】
No more using real katana for tourism activities, Japan’s National Police Agency says
Starbucks Japan reveals new sakura drinkware collection, inspired by evening cherry blossoms
Updated cherry blossom forecast shows extra-long sakura season for Japan this year
Human washing machine pods coming to Japanese hotels【Photos】
Umamusume anime girl plushie recalled for having parts she absolutely should not have【Pics】
End-of-the-Line Exploring in Japan: Tokyo’s Mita Line can give you all the nothing you want【Pics】
Why Do Foreigners Like Japan so Much? We Head to Comiket 82 to Find Out!
Japan Sets Guinness Record for Synchronized Mascot Dancing 【Video】
Adorable New “Pokemomo” Brand Goods Coming to Pokemon Center Stores Across Japan
“Office lady in heels walking on tatami”: The mysterious world of Japanese fetishism
Shiba Inu bring the cute and cuddly, leave us all wanting a snuggle
Dragon Ball Super Training Challenge! is ready to whip future defenders of the Earth into shape
Japanese beef bowl chain Sukiya’s 2026 Smile Box lucky bag basically pays for itself
Evangelion creator Hideaki Anno opens up about his latest bout with depression, movie delays
This Osaka laundromat wants to clean more than your clothes; it also wants to clean you
Things get heavy with the Gold Lucky Bag from Village Vanguard
“Foreign travelers are Japan’s guests” – Governor against charging tourists more than locals
Leave a Reply