Earlier this month, YouTube user NorniTube uploaded a controversial video of a social experiment which looked at how a person’s appearance can affect the responses they get from the general public. One two different days, he pretended to collapse on a Paris street to see if anyone would come to his aid, on one occasion wearing shabby clothes, on the other dressed in a smart suit. (We’ll leave you to watch the video to find out how it went!)
After watching NorniTube’s video, YouTuber Hei Nan decided to test the reactions of his fellow Taiwanese citizens by doing a similar experiment on the streets of his city. Were the Taiwanese more or less likely to help out that the Parisians in NorniTube’s video? Find out after the jump!
▼ Would you help a stranger on the street?
NorniTube’s video, which has been viewed more than six million times on YouTube, tested the reactions of the French population towards a shabbily dressed man and a man in a suit (both are played by NorniTube). He pretended to collapse in the exact same manner on the same street, but it seems like the passing Parisians would only stop to help a well-dressed stranger in distress. When he was dressed in untidy clothing, streams of people ignored him, even when he called for help.
▼ However, when he was dressed in a suit, people came to his aid in a matter of seconds.
The video sparked a debate, with some viewers commenting that they couldn’t believe how cold the passers-by were. Others reasoned that it is not uncommon to see homeless or drunk people lying on the streets of Paris, which is why people sometimes choose to ignore them to avoid unnecessary trouble.
Inspired by this video, Hei Nan decided to test the citizens of Taiwan. Believing that the people of Taiwan would definitely lend a hand, even to someone who isn’t dressed to the nines, Hei Nan decided to wear only an undershirt and jeans for the experiment.
True to his prediction, a couple of passers-by approached shortly after he “collapsed” from a feigned heart problem. When he told them that he had medication in his pocket, the kind ladies even looked for his medicine.
Hei Nan may have achieved his goal of showing that Taiwanese are generally warm and caring people, but some skeptical netizens are doubting the authenticity of his video, believing that it was a staged attempt. However, there are also commenters who gave Hei Nan the benefit of the doubt, saying that the Taiwanese achieved a flawless victory in this society showdown.
▼ Caring strangers helping Hei Nan with his medication.
How do you think the people in your country would react in such a situation? How would you react to a complete stranger in need of help?
It’s probably not the best thing to prejudge a person by looking at the clothes they wear, but societal norms are different in every country and it’s sometimes hard to tell if a person is truly in need of help as there are con men out there who put on a show to swindle a quick buck. Of course, it would be a wonderful deed to lend a helping hand, but be sure to protect yourself too, Rocketeers!
Taiwanese YouTuber’s punny pick-up line gets him a girl’s number in just 36 seconds
Honne vs Tatemae: When do Japanese people lie and when do they reveal their true feelings?
Anti-Asian Racism Social Experiment restores our faith in humanity【Video】
Japanese temple burns to the ground, fire burning inside for 1,200 years unharmed
Krispy Kreme Japan is bringing two special donuts to the most-forgotten big city in the country
Pizza Hut Japan’s drinkable curry pizza is here – Is it all we dreamed it would be?[Taste test]
Starbucks Japan hoping fans will go bananas for its new mottainai banana affogato Frappuccino
Man in Japan calls in bomb threat because he doesn’t want to go to his own work farewell party
Japan’s instant ramen snack theme park features an athletic course even adults can enjoy
Memorial bell inside Hiroshima’s Peace Park has been silenced, but for a sweet reason
Japan has a new cute and clever sunblock for cat lovers
Japanese vending machine find introduces us to a new drink you can’t get anywhere else
Japan’s izakaya pubs closing at record pace, failing to attract foreign tourists
Kanji ice cream becomes a sell-out hit in Japan
Tokyo’s life-size Gundam anime mecha statue will be removed this summer
Ichiraku Ramen-inspired ramen sets from Naruto anime pay homage to Naruto, Sasuke, and Sakura
This Tokyo Station sweets sensation sells out daily, but we finally got our hands on it
Hundreds of rose bushes in bloom at Tokyo’s off-the-beaten-path, next-to-the-tracks flower street
Studio Ghibli’s president is leaving the company. Will it change how they make anime?
Let’s hike a Japanese mountain (that isn’t Mt. Fuji) – Mt. Tsukuba[Photos]
The average age of Japan’s hikikomori shut-ins is getting older, survey shows
Japan enters Golden Week vacation period, survey shows one in three plan to ride it out at home
New Kyoto Converse sneakers celebrate Japan with traditional kimono fabrics for your feet
Japan’s new Pokémon jackets give you the look and powers of the Kanto starter trio
Japan now has gyoza doughnuts, and they taste like no other doughnut we’ve tried before
Japan’s 5.3 million beautiful Hitachi Nemophila flowers are now in full bloom[Photos]
Studio Ghibli launches huge new anime movie T-shirt collection with special design details
Japan’s human washing machines will go on sale to general public, demos to be held in Tokyo
Starbucks Japan releases new drinkware and goods for Valentine’s Day
We deeply regret going into this tunnel on our walk in the mountains of Japan
Starbucks Japan releases new sakura goods and drinkware for cherry blossom season 2026
Japan’s newest Shinkansen has no seats…or passengers [Video]
Major Japanese hotel chain says reservations via overseas booking sites may not be valid
Put sesame oil in your coffee? Japanese maker says it’s the best way to start your day【Taste test】
No more using real katana for tourism activities, Japan’s National Police Agency says
Japan reportedly adding Japanese language skill requirement to most common foreigner work visa