Be it drowning family members or rescuing neighbors from pits of crap, China continues to not disappoint in the things that make you go “hmmm” department.
This time, let’s say that the son of a wealthy family killed an innocent bystander while drag racing on city streets and is up on a variety of charges, possibly resulting in the death penalty.
In an effort to protect their unfortunate son, the family asks you to be his substitute in prison. The sentence is guaranteed to be reduced to – oh, let’s say 3 years – and you’ll get paid for every day of it. What would you do? What would you charge?
This exercise in morality, justice, and finance has a longstanding tradition in China, where it’s called ding zui, or “substitute criminals,” but it largely went unnoticed in the country and was often regarded as an urban legend until the rise of the internet.
The above example was suggested by Chinese netizens determined to shed light on this alleged system of prisoner swapping. The photo above shows what certainly seem to be two different people, 20 year-old Hu Bin on the right enjoying his freedom, and “the Defendant Hu Bin” on the left awaiting sentencing.
That was in 2009, but recently, due to the high profile trial of Gu Kailai for the murder of Neil Heywood in which some believe a stand-in was used, the practice has been gaining international attention.
It seems that subbing in a convict is often done when wealthier members of Chinese society get caught with vehicular offences. One example reported by Chinese media cites that an unlicensed driver who killed a motorcyclist had paid someone $8,000 to do his time for him.
For a more clear idea on the market rates for this sort of thing: when a demolition company accidentally tore down the wrong building, the owner negotiated to pay a man $31 a day for each day he spent behind bars.
It’s said that the elites of China are in no rush to change this system since paying substitute criminals amounts to the same thing as imposing a financial penalty – justice and all that stuff can take a walk.
Although it totally undermines the entire justice system that society kind of relies on to function, some might argue that is helps to stimulate the economy by adding valuable jobs to the lower classes. It’s like a new kind of trickle-down economics: murder-down economics!
Source: Slate via Oddity Central (English)
[ Read in Japanese ]

7 great places to see Mt. Fuji from without having to climb it
Final Fantasy and Shinkansen announce collaboration with in-train audio play, SD art and merch
Cyberpunk anime meets traditional culture in Ghost in the Shell gold leaf Japanese changing screens
Starbucks Japan ready to get Year of the Horse started with adorable drinkware and plushies【Pics】
Japanese avoiding domestic travel as foreign tourists increase, possibly creating vicious cycle
7 great places to see Mt. Fuji from without having to climb it
Final Fantasy and Shinkansen announce collaboration with in-train audio play, SD art and merch
Cyberpunk anime meets traditional culture in Ghost in the Shell gold leaf Japanese changing screens
Starbucks Japan ready to get Year of the Horse started with adorable drinkware and plushies【Pics】
Japanese avoiding domestic travel as foreign tourists increase, possibly creating vicious cycle
Sailor Moon and team to get new adversaries in “Black Moon Clan”
Turn a persimmon into a pudding with one simple ingredient
Our Japanese reporter offers up some safety advice for anyone traveling to Southeast Asia
Japanese Twitter user stumbles across legendary deep-sea fish, cooks and eats it four different ways
Senkoji: The Japanese temple that’s more like a theme park to heaven and hell
Disillusionment at Tsukiji’s tourist-target prices led us to a great ramen restaurant in Tokyo
Japan may add Japanese language proficiency, lifestyle classes to permanent foreign resident requirements
Lacquerware supplier to emperor of Japan and Pokémon team up for new tableware
Starbucks Japan releases new zodiac chilled cup drink for 2026
7-Eleven Japan’s ramen-cooking robot whipped us up a bowl of noodles【Taste test】
Japan’s otoshidama tradition of giving kids money at New Year’s gets a social welfare upgrade
Hello Kitty Choco Egg figures are an adorable trip through three periods of Japanese pop culture【Pics】
7-Eleven Japan starts new temporary luggage storage service in over 300 branches
Can a dirty butthole make you filthy rich in Japan? We’re starting a New Year’s lottery experiment
Japan’s human washing machines will go on sale to general public, demos to be held in Tokyo
Starbucks teams up with 166-year-old Kyoto doll maker for Year of the Horse decorations【Photos】
Tokyo considering law requiring more trash cans following litter increase in heavily touristed area
Tokyo’s Tsukiji sushi neighborhood asks tour groups to stay away for the rest of the month
Nintendo’s Kirby now delivering orders at Kura Sushi restaurants, but not in Japan
Tokyo event lets you travel back in time, for free, to celebrate 100 years since Showa era start
Sanrio theme park in Japan announces plans to expand into a Sanrio resort
Stamina-destroying “Paralysis Noodles” are Tokyo’s newest over-the-top ramen innovation
Survey asks foreign tourists what bothered them in Japan, more than half gave same answer
Japan’s deadliest food claims more victims, but why do people keep eating it for New Year’s?
We deeply regret going into this tunnel on our walk in the mountains of Japan
Studio Ghibli releases Kodama forest spirits from Princess Mononoke to light up your home
Major Japanese hotel chain says reservations via overseas booking sites may not be valid
Put sesame oil in your coffee? Japanese maker says it’s the best way to start your day【Taste test】
The top 10 annoying foreign tourist behaviors on trains, as chosen by Japanese people【Survey】
No more using real katana for tourism activities, Japan’s National Police Agency says
Starbucks Japan reveals new sakura drinkware collection, inspired by evening cherry blossoms
Sailor Moon and team to get new adversaries in “Black Moon Clan”
Turn a persimmon into a pudding with one simple ingredient
Our Japanese reporter offers up some safety advice for anyone traveling to Southeast Asia
Japanese Twitter user stumbles across legendary deep-sea fish, cooks and eats it four different ways
Senkoji: The Japanese temple that’s more like a theme park to heaven and hell
7-Eleven Japan’s ramen-cooking robot whipped us up a bowl of noodles【Taste test】
Lacquerware supplier to emperor of Japan and Pokémon team up for new tableware
Hello Kitty Choco Egg figures are an adorable trip through three periods of Japanese pop culture【Pics】
More Than a Capsule Stay: Why Solo Travelers Choose “global cabin Yokohama Chinatown”
Beautiful Japanese cosplayer stuns fans with high school photos that look nothing like her now
We go on a quest to find the cheesiest sushi at Japanese conveyor belt sushi chains【Taste test】
This dorayaki spot is one of the best sweets shop in Tokyo that people don’t know about yet
Leave a Reply