There’s been plenty of controversy about the casting and plot, but something else jumps out at me in the latest preview.
After years of rumors, halting half-starts, and teaser videos, it’s almost hard to believe that Paramount Pictures live-action Ghost in the Shell, adapted from the ground-breaking anime and manga of the same name, is actually going to start playing in theaters next month. As a matter of fact, the film is so close to release that Paramount has just released what looks to be the final preview, designated simply and definitively as “Ghost in the Shell (2017) – Official Trailer.”
But the last several months have also been filled with controversies for the production, the most prominent being the decision to cast Caucasian actress Scarlet Johansson in the lead role as cyborg-with-a-Japanese-name Motoko Kusanagi…or at least her live-action replacement. So far, the live-action Ghost in the Shell has pointedly refrained from using the name Motoko Kusanagi, unwaveringly referring to Johansson’s character as just “The Major,” the rank held by Kusanagi in the source material.
While the casting choice has met with a considerable backlash in the West, Japan seems largely okay with it, with many concluding that Johansson’s star power gives the film bigger box office potential (the Japanese film industry’s own penchant for changing the ethnicities of characters when adapting stories into new forms of media probably also makes it a little easier for the Japanese public to shrug its shoulders in acceptance).
But even if you’re OK with Johansson playing the lead, you can still take issue with what look like thematic changes Paramount is making to Ghost in the Shell. The official trailer’s dramatic dialogue includes lines such as. “Everything they told you was a lie. You had a family.” “They did not save your life. They stole it,” someone else tells The Major, and the protagonist then goes on to declare “They created me, but they cannot control me.”
After seeing Kusanagi’s single-minded determination on display so frequently in the anime and manga, some fans might be turned off by what they see as attempts to set up a clichéd “hero rebels against corrupt authority” storyline. Ghost in the Shell, after all, has usually been less about fighting the machine and more about becoming a machine, and there’s a certain realistic grittiness lent to the anime’s proceedings by the fact that its “heroes” aren’t always doing heroic things, but instead taking the best choice of action presented from among several imperfect options.
As someone who’s been an anime fan for a long, long time, the possible tonal shift doesn’t really bother me. I was there when manga loyalists complained that director Mamoru Oshii’s heavily philosophical 1995 Ghost in the Shell anime movie felt different from the original comic from series creator Masamune Shirow.
Then I was there when other people complained that director Kenji Kamiyama’s 2002 Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex TV anime series was mixing in more plot and spending less time musing about how technology affects the human soul than Oshii’s movie did. And you know what? Shirow’s manga, Oshii’s film, and Kamiyama’s TV series all remain extremely popular based on their respective, unique merits. Oshii has even mentioned in interviews that during the planning stages of his movie, he spoke with Shirow and was told to make whatever changes he wanted in order to tell the story he was envisioning.
Yet there’s still one thing that I find extremely annoying about the official trailer for Paramount’s Ghost in the Shell. The moment occurs at the 46-second mark, as Johansson is recreating Kusanagi’s famous “jump-off-a-skyscraper-and-turn-invisible-before-shooting-a-bunch-of-dudes” scene.
One of the building that can be seen in the background is lit up in an impressive display of cyberpunk neon, with Japanese text spelling out kokyu hoteru.
Now hoteru is just the corrupted Japanese pronunciation of “hotel,” so the sign is identifying the building as “kokyu hotel.” However, “kokyu” isn’t the name of a company or family, so it’s not like this is a branch of a chain called “Kokyu Hotel.”
All “kokyu hotel” means is “luxury hotel.”
While there’s nothing wrong with the phrase in and of itself, it’s pretty silly to think that a Japanese business would simply write “luxury hotel” on the side of its building, in what looks to be 50-floors’ worth of electric signage, without giving the actual name of the company/hotel. For anyone who can read the sign, it’s a distractingly unrealistic attempt to add some Japanese flair to the setting. It’s the sort of thing that anyone who reads Japanese and has spent any time in the country could point out as weird, and it’s surprising to think that Paramount apparently didn’t have even one person with that combination of linguistic skill and life experience take a look at the scene’s Japanese text.
In the film’s defense, the live-action Ghost in the Shell is yet to specify exactly where its story takes place, and even the manga and anime eschew designating a real Japanese city as the setting in favor of placing the characters and events in the vaguely defined New Port City. Still, it’s clear from the live-action Ghost’s skyline that the metropolis Johansson is running around is supposed to have, at the very least, major Japanese cultural instances.
Although honestly, that city looks more over-the-top-Japanese than any that actually exist in Japan.
Top image: YouTube/Paramount Pictures
Insert images: YouTube/Paramount Pictures, Kodansha
Follow Casey on Twitter, where he’s still less irked than he was by the gibberish “Japanese” on the street signs in the live-action Resident Evil: Extinction’s Tokyo scene.

Teaser trailers released for Hollywood’s live-action Ghost in the Shell movie【Videos】
Live-action Ghost in the Shell brings back main anime cast for its Japanese-dubbed version
“Ghost in the Shell for beginners” – Our Japanese film critic’s impressions of the Hollywood film
Dreamworks’ Ghost in the Shell film casts Sam Riley as villain
Live-action Ghost in the Shell recreates anime’s most famous fight scene in new preview 【Video】
Cherry blossom forecasts map shows Japan’s OTHER sakura season is starting right now
Ghost in the Sheel goes traditional with Japanese porcelain Tachikoma robots, only 50 to be made
Japan’s job-quitting service claims bosses contact it to try to make their employees quit
This gigantic judo dojo-sized hotel room will make you feel like royalty, but it’s disappearing soon
And now, we eat a bear paw we bought in Japan’s Chiba Prefecture【Taste test】
Japan cherry blossom forecast update moves up sakura dates for many parts of the country
Cherry blossom sake rice beer arriving in Japan well ahead of cherry blossom season, but how?
We tried Korea’s way-too-big King Tonkatsu Burger at Lotteria 【Taste Test】
Japan has a new bar just for people thinking about quitting their jobs, and the drinks are free
Majority of Japanese women in survey regret marrying their husband, but that’s only half the story
Yokai are descending upon Tokyo this spring in the latest immersive art experience
Japan’s Naruto theme park now offering real-world version of Minato’s kunai ninja weapon
New Studio Ghibli stamps leave an impression on your stationery…and your heart
Archfiend Hello Kitty appears as Sanrio launches new team-up with Yu-Gi-Oh【Pics】
Studio Ghibli turns My Neighbour Totoro characters into bag charms for everyday adventures
If you haven’t tried an antenna shop in Japan, you’re missing out
Studio Ghibli releases Spirited Away bags in Japan, based on a mysterious festival
Morning-after pill finally available in Japan without a prescription, must be taken at pharmacy
Starbucks Japan releases new drinkware and goods for Valentine’s Day
Japan releases first official sakura cherry blossom forecast for 2026
10 times to avoid traveling in Japan in 2026
Starbucks Japan releases new Frappuccino and latte for Valentine’s Day
Our 52-year-old pole dancing reporter shares his tips for achieving your New Year’s exercise goal
China’s don’t-go-to-Japan warning looks to be affecting tourist crowds on Miyajima
Studio Ghibli releases new “komorebi” plush toys from Princess Mononoke and Spirited Away
Ramen restaurant’s English menu prices are nearly double its Japanese ones, denies discriminating
Survey asks foreign tourists what bothered them in Japan, more than half gave same answer
Japan’s human washing machines will go on sale to general public, demos to be held in Tokyo
We deeply regret going into this tunnel on our walk in the mountains of Japan
Studio Ghibli releases Kodama forest spirits from Princess Mononoke to light up your home
Major Japanese hotel chain says reservations via overseas booking sites may not be valid
Put sesame oil in your coffee? Japanese maker says it’s the best way to start your day【Taste test】
No more using real katana for tourism activities, Japan’s National Police Agency says
Starbucks Japan reveals new sakura drinkware collection, inspired by evening cherry blossoms
Updated cherry blossom forecast shows extra-long sakura season for Japan this year
Scarlett Johansson: Live-action Ghost in the Shell begins filming in early 2016
Live-Action Ghost in the Shell Film Unveils 1st Full 2-Minute Trailer
Teaser trailer released for new Ghost in the Shell movie, set to open summer 2015 【Video】
Variety: Scarlett Johansson signs on to Hollywood’s Ghost in the Shell
Unhappy with live-action Ghost in the Shell? You’ll be happy to know a brand-new anime is coming
Live-action Ghost in the Shell movie casts its first Japanese actor: Beat Takeshi
Kodansha’s Sam Yoshiba supports Scarlett Johansson casting choice for Ghost in the Shell
Ghost in the Shell in costume as producers reveal cast photos, reason for no DVD plans
Cyberpunk anime meets traditional culture in Ghost in the Shell gold leaf Japanese changing screens
Mythbuster’s Adam Savage explores Ghost in the Shell’s coolest practical effects【Video】
Spirited Away and Ghost in Shell’s sound director talks about the human side of working in anime
New live-action Fullmetal Alchemist trailer shows off Ed’s mechanical arm, brother-in-armor Al
Anime/manga One-Punch Man to be turned into a Hollywood live-action movie
Netflix releases first trailer for its live-action American adaptation of anime Death Note【Video】
Leave a Reply