
This hidden hangout will transport you to another world.
In Japan, a lot of food from abroad is ‘Japanised’, adjusted slightly to suit local tastes, so it can be hard to find authentic food that’ll truly give you a taste of what it’s like to eat overseas.
So when our reporter Seiji Nakazawa recently read about a New York pizza place that had rave reviews from foreigners on Reddit, he immediately set out to try it, hopping on a train to Kodenmacho Station on the Tokyo Metro Hibiya Line.
▼ His destination? Pizza Slice Commissary.
“I finally found it after living in Japan for eight months!” was one of the exuberant comments that Seiji had read online, and Seiji had to admit that after years of living in Tokyo, he’d never been to this place let alone heard of it.
While Pizza Slice has two other branches in Tokyo — in Shibuya and Minato wards — the Commissary branch was in an area of Nihonbashi away from the main tourist sites, which is one of the reasons why it had never been on Seiji’s radar. The neighbourhood had a nice, laid-back feel to it, and after a short three-minute walk from the station, Seiji had arrived at his destination.
The Commissary blended so well into the building that Seiji may have walked past it if he wasn’t looking for it, but when he stepped inside, he felt as if he’d walked into another world.
The inside was set up like a food court, but it had a distinct foreign vibe to it, perhaps due to the spacious layout and concrete floors. The smell of foreign food wafted wonderfully in the air, and there was English-language signage everywhere.
Most of the customers were foreigners, which heightened the sense of being overseas, and Seiji suddenly felt a rush of excitement, as if he was on a journey in a foreign land, seeking out a slice of New York pizza.
He eventually found it in the middle of the Commissary, where he eagerly perused the menu, which was written in English and Japanese, with prices in yen written in a style that made them look more like dollars.
No cash payments can be made here, so Seiji whipped out his phone and made a cashless payment for a slice of Pepperoni and a slice of Chorizo & Jalapeno, priced at 550 yen (US$3.93) and 605 yen respectively.
▼ The pizzas were displayed by the window.
▼ Pepperoni (top) Chorizo & Jalapeno (bottom)
The first thing that struck Seiji was the size, with each slice being bigger than his face.
As it turns out, it wasn’t just the size that was impressive — the thin and crispy texture of the base was also fantastic.
▼ What you’d expect from a good New York slice.
Then there was the flavour, which sent Seiji straight to pizza heaven, with the stretchy cheese being a highlight. He couldn’t choose a favourite between the two, as the pepperoni was a classic and the Chorizo & Jalapeno had a spicy kick that made it equally delicious. They were both amongst some of the best pizzas he’s ever tasted, and now that he’s found Pizza Slice in Tokyo, he may never be able to go back to other pizzas again.
So thank you, Reddit, for introducing Seiji to a great New York pizza joint in Tokyo. He can certainly see why the place is so popular with foreigners, and once more people in Japan find out about it, he reckons the place will be overrun with locals too.
Now that he’s gotten a taste of New York, Seiji can hear the new KFC N.Y. chicken burgers calling his name!
Restaurant information
Pizza Slice Commissary
Address: Tokyo-to, Chuo-ku, Nihonbashi Honcho 3-11-5
東京都中央区日本橋本町3-11-5
Open: 11:00 a.m.-10:00 p.m.
Website
Images © SoraNews24
● Want to hear about SoraNews24’s latest articles as soon as they’re published? Follow us on Facebook and Twitter!










Noodle joint in Harajuku becomes a hot topic with foreigners on Reddit, but is it any good?
Japanese ramen chain becomes a hot topic with foreigners on Reddit, but is it any good?
Taste-testing Domino’s Pizza’s Tsundere Pizza with SoraNews24’s biggest otaku
Japanese curry chain is highly recommended by foreigners on Reddit, but is it any good?
Japanese curry chain becomes a hot topic with foreigners on Reddit, but is it any good?
Studio Ghibli unveils new My Neighbour Totoro Yearly Plate for 2027
New Japanese convenience store rice balls taste like instant noodles [Taste test]
Kyoto temple bans visitors from wearing kimono
Lego PlayStation recreates Sony’s original console, makes unusual choice for games to salute
Starbucks Japan releases new coffee table book featuring 18 of the most unique stores around the country
New Pokémon anniversary song is 22 minutes long, features all 1,025 Pokémon species [Video]
American tourist in Japan arrested on charges of attempted murder and arson
Japan’s Tsukimi One-hand Bento’s name is all wrong, but it still looks entirely delicious
Starbucks Japan reveals new Tsukimi Moon-Viewing drinkware and gifts for autumn 2026
Japan’s first fall color forecast for 2026 is here!
Studio Ghibli unveils new anime calendars and diary planners for 2027
Solo travel in Japan: Hidden beer garden in Tokyo is a haven for single visitors
Japan’s final Penguin Suica train cards have already shipped, and when they’re gone, they’re gone
Family Mart releases new Human Made Cup Noodle in Japan, with freebies for Nigo fans
A real-world Pokémon Poké Ball hotel is opening in Japan at a still-secret location [Video]
Hobonichi unveils new 2027 planners, diaries and stationery with One Piece, Suica Penguin, Hello Kitty and a must-buy Mini Techo
One Piece Day 2026 brings new art, music, and new cast announcements
Tamagotchi evolves into a ring for its 30th anniversary, preorders now open
12-year-old British girl who went missing in Tokyo found safe after visiting anime sites around Yokohama
7-year-old boy left behind on Mt. Fuji by his own dad
Sushi Bus: Japan’s first conveyor-belt bus lets you eat sushi while sightseeing around Tokyo
Japanese toilet aims to attract foreign tourists but not everybody is happy about it
New Japanese vending machine at Shinkansen station sells cups of ice on platform
Study finds hundreds of people in Indonesia legally named after Naruto, Inuyasha, other anime stars
Japan approves foreign resident visa renewal fee increases of up to 967 percent, starts soon
Japan tripled its departure tax to fund tourism but is using the money on cherry blossoms and bears
Japan announces sudden 400-percent increase in visa fees for foreigners entering the country
Japan’s human washing machines will go on sale to general public, demos to be held in Tokyo
Studio Ghibli has a new anime out, and there’s only one place in the world where you can see it
Starbucks Japan releases new drinkware and goods for Valentine’s Day
Starbucks Japan releases new sakura goods and drinkware for cherry blossom season 2026
Japan’s newest Shinkansen has no seats…or passengers [Video]
Tokyo subway installing new ticket gates that don’t accept payment through Suica or other IC cards
Japanese ninja certification exam attracts 131 candidates from Japan and abroad
Salomon releases Japan-exclusive Mt. Fuji hiking gear that doubles as an amazing souvenir
Put sesame oil in your coffee? Japanese maker says it’s the best way to start your day【Taste test】
Takoyaki store in Osaka becomes a hot topic on Reddit, but is it any good?
Japanese convenience store sandwich becomes a hot topic on Reddit, but is it any good?
Eel vendor in Asakusa becomes a hot topic with foreigners on Reddit, but is it any good?
Pizza Hut’s new rice pizzas debut in Japan, but are they any good?
Japanese bento shop becomes a hot topic with foreigners on Reddit, but is it any good?
Do Shibuya’s new Pizza Waffles taste as good as they sound?
Ichiran ramen restaurant in Shinjuku has a unique system that’s captured hearts on Reddit
Would a pizza made with pizza-flavored potato chips yield a super pizza?
Supermarket sushi becomes a hot topic with foreigners on Reddit, but is it any good?
Japanese restaurant chain selling not just folded pizzas, but LUCKY folded pizzas!
A visit to the birthplace of pizza toast: Is the original better than all the others out there?
Sakura Pizza from Domino’s Pizza Japan is here, but is it any good?【Taste test】
English-language Reddit falls in love with curry restaurant– Can it win our taste tester’s heart?
Japanese restaurant chain causes a stir with foreigners online, but is it any good?
Clever naming has New York diners raving about Japanese-style cod roe and pigs’ feet